Mackinac Island Fudge shops
Inhale the mouthwatering aromas. Partake in the deliriously delicious confectioneries. Revel in the experience – your palate will think it won the lottery!
The Island doesn’t claim to have created fudge. But after one taste, you’ll agree that it was perfected here. The flavors are unworldly.
Born in the years following the Civil War, the tradition of fudge making is stronger than ever and fudge remains the Island’s most popular and tastiest souvenir. (Yes, don’t forget to celebrate the endless joy of fudge with friends and family when you return from your Island retreat.)
Mackinac Island Fudge Festival
Be sure to enjoy the annual Mackinac Island Fudge Festival. It’s an unforgettable sensory experience.
Come to Joann’s for authentic Mackinac Island Fudge, made fresh daily with real cream, butter and only the finest natural ingredients. Joann’s offers 25 fantastic flavors as well as an assortment of hand-dipped chocolates and sugar-free candies. Gift packages, online ordering and shipping available. Several locations downtown.
May’s Candy Shops
May’s fudge shop has been family operated for four generations. This summer season we’ll be offering French Vanilla, Amaretto Chocolate Chip, Butter Pecan, Peanut Butter, Chocolate Nut and Plain Chocolate as well as our famous English toffee, Monsters, Pecan Rolls and Clusters. Free samples. Several locations downtown.
The original on the Island since 1887, Murdick’s has been serving fresh homemade fudge, peanut brittle, chocolate nut clusters and bark from the very best ingredients. Bring the whole family and watch our expert fudge makers create over 15 flavors of fudge and candies. Wedding fudge favors, gift packages, online ordering and shipping available. Several locations downtown.
Murray Hotel Fudge Company
Open from May through October. Made fresh daily in the Murray fudge kitchen. Innovative new flavors each season to tantalize your taste buds. Try s’mores, blueberry cheesecake, vanilla chocolate chip, heath, tiger, heavenly goo, coconut bon-bon, butterfinger and caramel apple pie. Order by phone, gift packages available. Located in the Murray Hotel downtown.
Available year round, Ryba’s Fudge has been voted “Michigan’s Favorite Fudge” three years running by the Detroit News. Ryba’s makes 14 delicious fudge flavors as well as handmade carmel corn and chocolates. Don’t forget to try our wonderful caramel apples. Gift packages, online ordering and shipping available. Several locations downtown.
Fred Sanders opened the first Sanders store in June of 1875 with a barrel of borrowed sugar, a leased shop and a confectioner’s dream. Sander’s still follows the simple standards of using the finest quality ingredients for their chocolates, candies and fudge toppings. Fred Sanders chocolates and toppings are still made following strict formulas by dedicated lifelong candy makers.
Velvet | A Candy Store
Mackinac Island’s newest fudge & candy shop. Featuring Mackinac Island fudge, delectable chocolates, pinwheel suckers, candies, brittle, saltwater taffy, homemade ice cream and delicious treats. Pretty gift baskets and shipping available. Located in the center of Main Street.